En
Search toggle
En
Search toggle
Choose your language.

Most civil teams that ask "should we use Vault or the cloud?" are really asking a different question: why does nobody trust which file is current?

Civil projects rarely go wrong because a team lacks software. They go wrong because information moves unpredictably — between drives, email attachments, shared links and the reviewer who printed the drawing last week. Picking a platform before you have fixed that tends to move the problem into a new location.

So start somewhere else.

Three stages every civil project goes through

Whatever tools you use, project information passes through the same three stages.

Authoring. Engineers build surfaces, alignments, corridors and pipe networks in Civil 3D. Files reference each other constantly through data shortcuts and xrefs. The priority here is control: who is editing what, and keeping references intact.

Release. At some point work-in-progress becomes something you are willing to share: a submission, a review set, an issued-for-construction package. The priority is governance: a clear line between draft and approved, and a record of who approved it.

Collaboration and distribution. Reviewers, owners, contractors and other consultants need to see and comment on the right version. The priority is access: the right people, the right set, without emailing PDFs.

A data strategy is just a decision about which environment handles each stage, and how information crosses between them.

Where each Autodesk environment fits

Autodesk Vault is on-premises engineering data management. It is strongest at the authoring stage: check-in and check-out, version history, lifecycle states and managing the relationships between Civil 3D files. Organizations that need authoring data on their own servers, or that have heavy, interdependent Civil 3D datasets, often keep authoring in Vault.

Forma Data Management (formerly Autodesk Docs) is Autodesk's cloud common data environment. It handles file management, review and approval workflows, issued sets and controlled sharing with external stakeholders. Many teams also author directly in it, using Civil 3D with Autodesk Desktop Connector.

Forma Design Collaboration (formerly BIM Collaborate Pro) adds structured design collaboration and coordination between teams and disciplines working in the cloud.

None of these is the "right" answer on its own. They are tools for different stages.

Three patterns we see in practice

Cloud-first. Authoring, release and sharing all happen in Forma Data Management. Works well for distributed teams and firms without an on-premises server culture. The key is disciplined folder structure and permissions so Civil 3D references survive.

Vault for authoring, cloud for release. Engineers work in Vault; released packages are published to Forma Data Management for review and distribution. Works well where authoring data needs to stay internal or datasets are large and tightly linked.

Cloud collaboration for specific projects. A firm runs mostly on-premises but uses Forma for projects where the owner or a partner requires a shared environment. Works if project setup is templated, so each cloud project doesn't start from scratch.

Questions to answer before choosing

  • Where must authoring data physically live, and why? Contract, policy, performance or habit?
  • How many offices and outside firms author on the same project?
  • What does "issued" mean for you, and who approves it?
  • What will an owner ask to see five years after handover?
  • Who maintains templates, permissions and naming once the system is live?

If those answers are unclear, a platform decision will not make them clearer.

Pilot before you scale

Whichever pattern fits, prove it on one active project before rolling it out. A pilot tests the parts that break in real life: Civil 3D references after files move, review workflows with an external reviewer, and whether the team actually follows the release process under deadline pressure. Fix those once, turn them into templates, then scale.

Where SolidCAD fits

SolidCAD supports civil organizations across Vault, Forma Data Management and Forma Design Collaboration, so we don't need you to pick one before we start. The starting point is a Civil Data Management Assessment: a review of current storage, naming and release practices, with a recommended target workflow.

From there the work usually runs in two further stages. Release workflows, sharing rules and project structure are set up and tested on a live project, with training for CAD managers, project managers and designers. Then templates, permissions and naming are standardized across teams, with onboarding documentation and ongoing health checks.

Frequently asked questions

Can Civil 3D work directly in Forma Data Management?

Yes. Civil 3D users commonly work with cloud-hosted files through Autodesk Desktop Connector, including data shortcuts, provided the folder structure is planned for it.

Do we need Vault if we use the cloud?

Not necessarily. Vault makes most sense where authoring data needs to stay on-premises or where version control of tightly linked datasets is a priority.

We already use SharePoint. Isn't that enough?

File storage alone does not govern engineering release, Civil 3D references or approval records. Those need a defined workflow, whichever system holds the files.

Where should we start?

With the release stage. Agreeing what "issued" means, and who approves it, fixes more version disputes than any platform change.

Related reading

Next step

Bring one active project and its current folder structure to a conversation. We'll show you where information is getting lost, and which pattern fits how your teams actually deliver.

Prefer email? Reach SolidCAD at info@solidcad.ca.

Book a Civil Data Management Assessment.

Unlock expert insights: connect with SolidCAD today!

Discover how SolidCAD Insights can accelerate your business growth and transformation. From industry trends to practical strategies, our experts are here to help. Contact us today to discuss your needs and explore solutions tailored to your business.